The Fenn Treasure: A Deadly Riddle in the Rockies

    Treasure Seeking with PNW Haunts & Homicides!

    Listen to the episode

    Episode Summary

    In this riveting episode of "Rainy Day Rabbit Holes," we delve into the captivating tale of Finn's Treasure, a modern treasure hunt that has enchanted adventurers and treasure seekers across the United States and beyond. The episode features a collaborative discussion with the spirited hosts from PNW Haunts and Homicides, who bring their unique blend of humor and intrigue to the exploration of this fascinating mystery.

    The story begins with Forrest Fenn, an art dealer, author, and Vietnam War veteran, who in 2010 launched one of the most thrilling treasure hunts in American history. After battling cancer, Fenn decided to hide a bronze chest filled with gold, jewels, and rare artifacts somewhere in the Rocky Mountains, challenging people to seek it out using a cryptic 24-line poem published in his memoir, "The Thrill of the Chase." Listeners will be treated to an analysis of this enigmatic poem, with its phrases hinting at locations such as "begin it where water's halt" and references to the elusive "home of Brown." The hosts dissect each stanza, weaving in humor while pondering the various interpretations of Fenn’s clues.

    As the episode unfolds, we learn how the allure of the treasure sparked a massive cultural phenomenon. Over 300,000 people joined the hunt, embarking on journeys into the wild wilderness of the Rockies, fueled by the promise of adventure and the potential for wealth. The discussion touches on the communities that formed around the hunt—online forums and social media groups brimming with speculation, theories, and even heated debates about the treasure's location. With the line between obsession and passion often blurred, the episode reflects on the psychological and emotional stakes involved in such a tantalizing pursuit.

    However, not all was light-hearted in the treasure-seeking escapade. The hosts candidly address the darker side of the hunt: the tragic loss of life and the environmental damage incurred as seekers ventured into perilous terrain. Despite warnings from authorities, many ignored the risks involved, driven by the tantalizing mystery of the hunt.

    In a twist of fate, the treasure was ultimately found in June 2020, but the identity of the finder and the exact location remain shrouded in secrecy. The reveal sparked a flurry of skepticism and frustration among the many who dedicated time and resources to the quest, raising questions about the true nature of Fenn’s treasure hunt—was it a genius act of inspiration or a reckless gamble?

    Listeners will leave this episode with a deeper understanding of the cultural impact of the Fenn Treasure saga and the complexities of human ambition in the face of mystery. So, grab your headphones, and prepare to fall down the rabbit hole of treasure, adventure, and the indomitable human spirit. This episode is perfect for anyone intrigued by the intersections of history, mystery, and the great outdoors, and it invites you to ponder: how far would you go for a treasure?

    In this collaborative episode, Rainy Day Rabbit Holes joins forces with Caitlyn and Cassie from PNW Haunts and Homicides to explore one of the strangest modern treasure hunts in history: Forrest Fenn’s hidden chest.

    Presented by Caitlyn, the story follows art dealer and Vietnam veteran Forrest Fenn, who in 2010 announced that he had hidden a bronze treasure chest somewhere in the Rocky Mountains—worth millions—and released a cryptic poem meant to lead seekers to it. What began as a whimsical riddle quickly spiraled into a decade-long obsession involving online sleuths, wilderness expeditions, lawsuits, environmental damage, and tragic deaths.

    Along the way, we unpack the poem’s clues, popular interpretations (including the infamous “home of Brown”), the massive online communities that formed around the hunt, and the ethical questions raised when adventure turns dangerous. The episode closes with a tarot reading that eerily mirrors the story’s ultimate lesson: knowing when to walk away.

    Equal parts mystery, cautionary tale, and cultural phenomenon, this episode asks: when does the thrill of the chase stop being worth the cost?


    Follow PNW Haunts and Homicides on all the platforms!

    https://www.pnwhauntsandhomicides.com/



    Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/history-unhinged-rainy-day-rabbit-holes/exclusive-content


    Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands


    Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    April 22, 2026

    Episode Gallery

    The Fenn Treasure: A Deadly Riddle in the Rockies episode image

    The Fenn Treasure: A Deadly Riddle in the Rockies episode image

    3750a760007098074b7c8b63e4526b6964a58423-4592x3108

    3750a760007098074b7c8b63e4526b6964a58423-4592x3108

    b1c8ff-20141222-abw-forrestfenn

    b1c8ff-20141222-abw-forrestfenn

    forrest-fenn-resized

    forrest-fenn-resized

    US190506A

    US190506A

    Sources and Links

    Episode Location

    Wyoming, United States

    Loading map...

    Lat: 43.544459Lng: -107.539858

    Frequently Asked Questions