Listen to the episode
Episode Summary
What begins as a simple exploration quickly spirals into a deep dive into the cemetery's unhinged history, where an astonishing tale of a murder for just $3.85 unfolds. This shocking crime, shrouded in mystery and scandal, reveals the darker side of Seattle’s past and highlights the complexities of human nature when desperation sets in. Shea and Jody dissect the social climate of the time, drawing connections to the economic struggles that led to such a gruesome act, and they invite listeners to ponder the broader implications of crime and morality in a rapidly changing world.
As the rain continues to fall, the hosts venture further into Lakeview Cemetery, revealing the poignant stories of Civil War veterans who have long been forgotten by history. These brave men, who fought valiantly in one of America’s most tumultuous periods, are memorialized in the cemetery, yet their tales often go untold. Shea and Jody illuminate the lives of these soldiers, delving into their sacrifices and the lasting impact of the Civil War on the Pacific Northwest. By connecting these veterans to the rich tapestry of Seattle's history, they offer a poignant reminder of the courage and resilience that shaped the region.
Throughout the episode, Shea and Jody's infectious humor and lively banter keep listeners engaged, blending the macabre with moments of light-heartedness. With each twist and turn, they invite curious travelers, true crime enthusiasts, and history buffs to immerse themselves in the stories that echo through the rain-soaked grounds of Lakeview Cemetery.
Listeners will be enchanted by the vivid descriptions of the cemetery’s haunting beauty, the intriguing historical anecdotes, and the emotional resonance of the tales shared. From the chilling $3.85 murder to the valor of Civil War heroes, this episode promises to be a roller-coaster ride through Seattle's dark past, reminding us that history is never just a series of dates and events, but a living tapestry woven with the threads of human experience. So grab your umbrella and tune in to this unforgettable adventure—there's so much more to uncover in the enchanting world of "Rainy Day Rabbit Holes."
What do a $3.85 murder, torrential rain, and Civil War vets have in common? They’re all part of Lakeview Cemetery’s unhinged history—and Shea and Jody are here for every wild minute.
In this hilarious and haunting episode of Rainy Day Rabbit Holes, Shea and Jody brave Seattle’s atmospheric river to explore Lakeview Cemetery with Richard from Seattle History Tours.
From true crime tales of $3.85 murder to Civil War veterans' untold stories, this tour was a wild ride through the West’s forgotten tragedies. Whether you're a true crime addict, history buff, or curious traveler, you’ll be hooked.
👉 Bonus content, ad-free episodes, and awesome perks await at rainydayrabbitholes.com/support!
🌧 Visit our website at rainydayrabbitholes.com for more!
Chapters with Timestamps:
- 00:00 - Welcome: From History Haters to Nerds
- 04:30 - Why We Took the Lakeview Cemetery Tour
- 10:00 - Atmospheric River Madness
- 15:40 - $3.85 Murder: The Charles Nordstrom Story
- 22:00 - Seattle’s Wild Cemetery Figures
- 30:00 - Dreaming of Giant Gravestones
- 40:00 - Shea’s One-Star Review Vendetta
- 45:00 - How You Can Support the Show
- Book a tour with Seattle History Tours / Civil War Seattle
Seattle history, Lakeview Cemetery, true crime podcast, Victorian history, unhinged history, Civil War Seattle, Seattle tours, Western history podcast, Seattle cemetery stories
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/history-unhinged-rainy-day-rabbit-holes--6271663/support.
Episode Gallery

Seattle’s haunted Lakeview Cemetery
Chapters
Sources and Links
- Lakewood Cemetary website
https://lakeviewseattle.com/
Episode Location
Lakeview Cemetary, Kirkland, Washington, United States
Loading map...
